This sign is hanging up at bus stops around Glover Park. I'm not trying to judge someone on their brand of footwear but I honestly do not think the cost of Aldo shoes warrants a reward for someone returning it. Even if it was brand new at the time of its disappearance (which I seriously doubt..I bet she was dancing about in the frat sludge at Gin & Tonic moments before). And if you are losing a single shoe at 3am on a Friday one must assume you took them off. And losing a shoe is minimal punishment for walking around the city barefoot. You should just be thankful and go buy yourself a new pair of shoes in celebration that you did not catch any terrible city foot disease.
Also, "went missing"? She should just be honest here...or at least creative. I'm sure if she included a little background information regarding the shenanigans occuring at the time of shoe loss...well, I might be a little more inclined to help.